Ghostbusters isn’t the only franchise to be recast with female leads – and that’s not necessarily a victory for equality.

When Bridesmaids was released in 2011 it broke new ground for female-centric blockbusters. Since then, however, Hollywood has moved away from making original women-led films towards ‘sheboots’, where a popular franchise is recast with the male roles going to women. The next in production is Ocean’s Ocho, the latest remake of Ocean’s Eleven, which will see the primary conmen played by Sandra Bullock and Cate Blanchett. Although it has been stressed that the actors will not be playing lady-versions of the male roles, it will be interesting to see what Olivia Milch is able to do with the screenplay within the constraints of the genre.

Then, of course, there’s Ghostbusters, to date the most talked-about sheboot. Director Paul Feig has complained that people only mention his film with the premise of the ‘all-female’ version and that we don’t talk about ‘the all-male Expendables’. Well, we’re fairly certain that if you recast Steel Magnolias with men in the lead roles people would refer to it as the ‘all-male’ Steel Magnolias. Whichever way you slice it, in their current guise gender swap movies are not a sign of progress for women in the film industry.

Hollywood often experiences trends where everyone jumps on the same bandwagon off the back of a single success. It’s lazy but perhaps to be expected in this risk averse business. Yet there is a positive sea change occurring, with several roles that were written for men being adapted for women – from Julia Roberts in Secret in their Eyes to Emily Blunt in Sicario and Charlize Theron in The Gray Man. We need more of this open-mindedness about the gender of lead characters, but it shouldn’t be done for the sake of it. Don’t make James Bond ‘Jane’ Bond; write a new deadly super spy who just happens to be a woman.

Female actors – not to mention moviegoers – deserve better than safe gender swap reboots. At a time when Hollywood is no longer able to hide its head in the sand with regards to certain inequalities, we may well look back on this time as a transitional phase towards a brighter future for women. The worry for now is that if films like Ghostbusters and Ocean’s Ocho prove successful, Hollywood might see gender swap films as a long-term solution. Equally, if these films perform badly at the box office, it will likely be seen as a failed experiment.

We need to see unconventional screenplays written with female actors in mind. We need women producers pushing the agenda to get these films made, and a greater opportunities for women behind the camera. Despite the disappointing backlash to Ghostbusters, it’s clear that audiences are ready to see more collaborations between predominantly female casts and crews – all we need now is for Hollywood to answer the call.

This article appeared on Little White Lies, click here for the article